RIP ‘SECULAR’. WELCOME ‘PLURAL’

 

The first among the many in The Constitution (Forty Second Amendment) Act 1976 says:

(a)    for the words "SOVEREIGN DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC" the words "SOVEREIGN
SOCIALIST SECULAR DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC" shall be substituted

The process by which the amendment took place was wholly unconstitutional and illegal but it is too late in the day to go into that. It would be useful for those who were either not born or too young to read how and under what circumstances the amendment bill was passed in the parliament.

 

Four decades and four years later, after flogging the word Secular to death, it has dawned on some people that the returns on that are tending towards zero.  So one of the flagbearers of secularism has come up with a brilliant idea.  Let’s call it Plural instead.

So, if she had the power, The Constitution (105th Amendment) Act 2020, would amend the preamble as

for the words "SOVEREIGN SOCIALIST SECULAR DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC" the words "SOVEREIGN SOCIALIST PLURAL DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC" shall be substituted

and bingo, all problems solved!

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/bloody-mary/secular-is-a-phony-word-citizens-must-work-for-a-modern-society-based-on-individual-rights-and-freedom/

The Congress Party uses the interesting tactic of “distancing themselves” from any uncomfortable statements made by one of their ilk. This goes a step beyond the diplomatic statement ‘we neither confirm nor deny’

It is interesting to see the journalists who were a part of the Secular Caravan now distancing themselves from the Congress Party and their brand of pseudo secularism.

These are the same people who, by their proximity to the Congress Party, found their foothold, rose to fame, made their money, enjoyed their perks ranging from 2BHKs to Farmhouses, on board champagne while flying with the PM to being able to interfere in the selection of cabinet portfolios etc. The fact that they are all now jumping the ship is proof enough that the ship is sinking, if not already sunk.

Let’s remind ourselves what these ‘Seculars’ did and said over the last few years to prove their Secularism.

Sagarika Ghose and Barkha Dutt tweeted/replied  mocking the Hindu ritual of Karwa Chauth. They do it every year. I am sure it will be very reassuring for the Hindus to know that their mocking is due to ‘Pluralism’ and not Secularism.  

A true liberal celebrates when women in Iran defy the norms and do what is prohibited for them like doing away with hijab, driving etc. But we have our very own Barkha who found fault with Chess Grandmaster Soumya Swaminathan who pulled out of a tournament in Iran over the country’s headscarf rule. Instead of applauding her, ‘she should have followed the norms of the land’ was all she had to say. Not applicable to her when she mocks the festival of Raksha Bandhan which she did ten days ago.

This kind of Anti Hindu bias was earlier called Secular. It is now proposed to be called Plural. It only shows the singular lack of understanding of the issue by these seculars.

Give it what name you will. A bias is a bias is a bias.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Of Sheep and Cattle, Horses and MLAs

The time has come,' the Walrus said,       To talk of many things: Of shoes — and ships — and sealing-wax —       Of cabbages — and kings — And why the sea is boiling hot —       And whether pigs have wings.'                                                             Lewis Carroll In the past few weeks, we have witnessed a spectacle which is routine in Indian politics but sadly, nauseating. I must confess that I am personally happy with the end result, being a BJP supporter, but not at all happy about the events leading to it. Hence readers can be assured that my below comments will be...
Read more

THE FAIZ CONTROVERSY

Allegory is a literary device used by poets to convey thoughts through symbols while the literal meaning of what is written maybe something different. It is particularly useful in political context when direct criticism of those in power could land the writer in trouble. Veiled metaphors are used instead. It is natural that a revolutionary poet like Faiz Ahmed Faiz used this tool very effectively as he was very critical of the oppressive regime in Pakistan. We have great poets who penned inspiring lines during our freedom struggle. My personal favourite is Bismil’s “sarfaroshi ki tamanna ab hamare dil mein hai,   Dekhna hai zor kitna bazue kaatil mein hai”. It isn’t mere coincidence that the agitating “students” of IIT Kanpur chose a Pakistani poet Faiz and the choice of the poem Hum Dekhenge is no coincidence either. Only the really naïve would believe that these protesters were referring to the hidden meaning in the lines ‘bas naam rahega allah ka’ or ‘but ko hata ...
Read more

KHAYAL DESH KI

05 April 2020 Kisiko balcony nahin to kisi ke paas mombathi bhi nahin, Pehchan pucho toh kehte hain mere paas kagaz bhi nahin Thali thoko ya nahin, diya jalao ya na jalao, marzi apni Raat din mehnat karte hue doctoron ka daad bhi nahin? Aage bahut zindagi padi hai yaron azadi se jee lena Yeh mahamari ka waqt Qayamat ka ehsaas bhi nahin? Hukumat pe naraz hona Ghalib zayad hai lekin, Itna gussa ke naaz apne hi watan pe bhi nahin?
Read more